PROBLEMS OF THE SOURCES THAT FORMED SUFISM IN THE ANALYSIS OF COMPARATIVE SUFI STUDIES
Keywords:
religion, Islam, Sufism, Sufi studies, mysticism, philosophical and mystical schools, comparative analysis, comparative Sufi studies, Buddhism, Zoroastrianism, Christianity, ManichaeismAbstract
In world Oriental and Islamic studies, there are different views on religious and philosophical teachings that have influenced and contributed to the emergence and formation of the teachings of Sufism. Some European Orientalists seek to identify the roots of Sufism in Western civilization, namely, in ancient philosophy and Christian religion, while other researchers are looking for the roots of Sufism in ancient Indian religions, both Vedic and non-Vedic, for example, in Buddhism, as well as in the religions of Ancient Iran – Mazdeism, Zoroastrianism and Manichaeism. Another group of Oriental and European scholars also believe that the true source of Sufism is the religion of Islam.
This article is devoted to the study and comparative analysis of these discussions. According to the author, in every religious and philosophical doctrines there are mystical principles similar to the Sufi teaching in Islam and the philosophy of mysticism. Comparative study and analysis of these mystical principles and Sufism in Islam allows us to study the essence of these doctrines even more deeply.
References
Комил инсон ҳақида тўрт рисола. / Форс тилидан Нажмиддин Комилов таржимаси. – Тошкент: “Маънавият”, 1997.
Абдуллаев А. Тасаввуф ва унинг намояндалари. – Термиз, 2007.
Miguel Asin Palacios. El Islam Cristiani rado. – Madrid, 1932.
Carra de Vaux. Gazali. Paris, 1902.
Nicholson R.A. The Idea of Personality in Sufism. – New Delhi, 1976.
Гольдциер И. Лекции об исламе. – Санкт-Петербург: Брокгауз-Ефрон, 1912.
Бартольд В.В. Учёные мусульманского «Ренессанса». //Соч. Т. VI. – Москва, 1966.
Из философского наследия народов Ближнего и Среднего востока. – Ташкент: “Фан”, 1972.
Усмон Нурӣ Тӯпбаш. Тасаввуф. – Душанбе: Гурӯҳи нашриётии паёми “САБЗ”, 2014.
بدوی، عبدالرحمن. تاریخ تصوف اسلامی. از آغاز سده دوم هجری./ ترجمه محمودرضا افتخارزاده. - تهران: دفتر نشر اسلامی، ۱۳۷۵
Шайх Муҳаммад Содиқ Муҳаммад Юсуф. Нақшбандия. Вазифалар. Зикрлар. – Тошкент: “Nihol-nashr”, 2018.
عطار، فرید الدین. منطق الطیر. - تهران، ۱۳۴۰. – ص.۲۷۶
حضرت شیخ المشایخ جنید بغدادی. // فرید الدین عطار. تذکرة الاوليأ. / با مقدمه و تصحىح محمد استعلامی. - تهران، ١٣٨٤. - ص. ٨٩
. - ص. ۱۰۵ تهران،۱۳۴۳ - سرچشمه های تصوف در ایران. نفیسی، سعید.
Комилов Н. Тасаввуф. Биринчи китоб. – Тошкент, 1996.
انصاری، عبدالله. صد میدان. - کابل، ۱۳۴۱. - ص. ۴
Ҳаким ат-Термизийнинг ушбу номдаги китоби фақат шу манбада тилга олинади.
الهجويرى الغزنوى، ابوالحسن على بن عثمان الجلابى. كشف المحجوب. / متن انتقادى و. ژوکوفسکی. - تهران: نشر اناصری، ۱۳۷۶. - ص. ۵۰