CONCEPTUAL APPROACHES TO THE STAGES OF COMMITTING A CRIME IN CRIMINAL LAW DOCTRINE
Keywords:
stages related to a crime, stages related to the application of a criminal norm, stages of criminal law qualification, stages of committing a crime, preparation for a crime, attempt to commit a crime, intent, incomplete crime, voluntary refusal to commit a crimeAbstract
The study of the stages of committing a crime is one of the key issues in criminal law, as these stages reflect the dynamics of criminal behavior and allow us to determine the point at which a person’s actions become socially dangerous, as well as to assess the degree of completion of the criminal act. Within the framework of criminal law doctrine, various approaches have been developed to define the boundaries and content of such stages as preparation, attempt, and completion of a crime. These conceptual approaches not only reflect theoretical views on the nature of criminal behavior but also have a significant impact on law enforcement practice.
Different legal systems and academic schools vary in their understanding of which actions should be classified as criminal from the early stages of preparation, and how to differentiate the punish ability at different stages. This study focuses on analyzing these theoretical approaches and their evolution in criminal law. It also explores how these concepts are reflected in legislation and judicial practice, which is crucial for improving the effectiveness of crime prevention and ensuring fair justice.
The aim of this study is to systematize existing concepts of the stages of committing a crime, to identify their strengths and weaknesses, and to analyze their significance for the practical qualification of acts.
References
Кушбаков Ж.А. Қасддан жиноят содир этиш босқичлари //The Role of Exact Sciences in the Era of Modern Development. – 2023. – Т. 1. – №. 4. – Б. 102. (Kushbakov J.A. Stages of Intentional Crime Commission //The Role of Exact Sciences in the Era of Modern Development. – 2023. – Vol. 1. – No. 4. – P. 102.)
Благов Е.В. Начало учения об уголовно-правовых стадиях: монография. – Москва: Проспект, 2023. – С. 8. (Blagov E.V. The Beginning of the Doctrine of Criminal Law Stages: Monograph. – Moscow: Prospekt, 2023. – P. 8.)
Козлов А.П. Учения о стадиях преступления. СПб., 2002. 353 с. (Kozlov A.P. The Doctrine of Crime Stages. St. Petersburg, 2002. 353 p.)
Сабитов Р.А. Теория и практика уголовно-правовой квалификации. М., 2013. С. 17-18, 41-46. (Sabitov R.A. Theory and Practice of Criminal Law Qualification. Moscow, 2013. Pp. 17-18, 41-46.)
Зацепин А.М. Дополнительная квалификация преступления: доктрина и практика: дисс. …д-ра юрид.наук. Екатеринбург, 2019. 48-58. (Zatsepin A.M. Additional Qualification of a Crime: Doctrine and Practice: Doctoral Dissertation in Law. Yekaterinburg, 2019. Pp. 48-58.)
Таганцев Н. С. Курс русского уголовного права. Часть Общая. Кн. 1. – СПб., 1878. -С. 126-127 (Tagantsev N.S. Course of Russian Criminal Law. General Part. Book 1. – St. Petersburg, 1878. – Pp. 126–127.)
Малцев В.В. Курс российского уголовного права. Общая часть. В 4 т. Т. III Кн I. М., 2017. С. 229. (Maltsev V.V. Course of Russian Criminal Law. General Part. In 4 Volumes. Vol. III, Book I. Moscow, 2017. P. 229.)
Уголовное право. Общая часть / под ред. В.Н.Петрашева. М., 1999. С. 225 (Criminal Law. General Part / edited by V.N. Petrashev. Moscow, 1999. P. 225.)
Рустамбаев М.Х.Ўзбекистон Республикаси Жиноят кодексига шарҳлар. Умумий қисм/М.Рустамбаев –Тошкент: Yuridik adabiyotlar publish, 2021. – Б.228-229 (Rustambaev M.Kh. Commentary on the Criminal Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. General Part / M. Rustambaev – Tashkent: Yuridik adabiyotlar publish, 2021. – Pp. 228-229)
Тедеев К.Т. Стадии совершения преступления и конструкции составов: автореф.дисс. …канд.юрид.аук. М., 2005. 29 с. (Tedeev K.T. Stages of Crime Commission and the Structure of Crime Elements: Abstract of the Dissertation for the Degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences. Moscow, 2005. 29 p.)
Бабий Н.А. Учения о стадиях престпления и неоконченных преступлениях. М., 2017. С. 92 (Babiy N.A. The Doctrine of Crime Stages and Incomplete Crimes. Moscow, 2017. P. 92.)
Редин М.П. Преступления по степени их завершенности. М., 2006. С. 12. (Redin M.P. Crimes by Degree of Completion. Moscow, 2006. P. 12.)
Ермакова О.В. Проблемы определения стадий совершения преступления // Алтайский юридический вестник. 2017. №4. С. 91. (Ermakova O.V. Problems of Defining the Stages of Crime Commission // Altai Law Bulletin. 2017. No. 4. P. 91.)
Жукова Т. Г. Уголовная ответственность за приготовление к преступлению и покушение на преступление: дис. … канд. юрид. наук. – Ставрополь, 2005. С. 27 (Zhukova T.G. Criminal Liability for Preparation for a Crime and Attempt to Commit a Crime: Dissertation for the Degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences. – Stavropol, 2005. – P. 27.)
Безуглый С.Н. Ответственность за неоконченное преступление по уголовному законодательству Российской Федерации: проблемы теории и практики. Дисс. канд.юрид.наук. – Блгород, 2017. –С. 40-41. (Bezugly S.N. Liability for Incomplete Crime under the Criminal Legislation of the Russian Federation: Problems of Theory and Practice. Dissertation for the Degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences. – Belgorod, 2017. – Pp. 40-41.)
Назаренко Г.В. Русское уголовное право. Общая часть. М., 2000. С. 117. (Nazarenko G.V. Russian Criminal Law. General Part. Moscow, 2000. P. 117.)
Уголовное право России (общая часть) с элементами сравнительного правоведения: учебник / коллектив авторов; под.ред. О.А.Ястребова, Л.А.Букалеровой. –Москва: КНОРУС, 2021. –С.230. (Criminal Law of Russia (General Part) with Elements of Comparative Jurisprudence: Textbook / Collective of Authors; Edited by O.A. Yastrebov, L.A. Bukalerova. – Moscow: KNORUS, 2021. – P. 230.)
Анисимов А.А. Неоконченные преступления и особенности их доказывания: автореф дисс. …канд.юрид.наук. Воронеж. 2003. - С.7, 12. (Anisimov A.A. Incomplete Crimes and Features of Their Proof: Abstract of the Dissertation for the Degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences. Voronezh, 2003. – Pp. 7, 12.)
Уголовное право России (общая часть) с элементами сравнительного правоведения: учебник / коллектив авторов; под.ред. О.А.Ястребова, Л.А.Букалеровой. –Москва: КНОРУС, 2021. –С.230. (Criminal Law of Russia (General Part) with Elements of Comparative Jurisprudence: Textbook / Collective of Authors; Edited by O.A. Yastrebov, L.A. Bukalerova. – Moscow: KNORUS, 2021. – P. 230.)
Некрасов В. Н. Нормы о неоконченном преступлении: проблемы законодательной техники и дифференциации ответственности: автореф. дис. … канд. юрид. наук. – Екатеринбург, 2013. С. 7-8. (Nekrasov V.N. Provisions on Incomplete Crimes: Problems of Legislative Technique and Differentiation of Liability: Abstract of the Dissertation for the Degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences. – Yekaterinburg, 2013. – Pp. 7-8.)
Синяева М.И., Скокова А.Н. Стадии совершения преступления в уголовном праве и уголовно-правовой науке // Уголовное право в эволюционирующем обществе: проблемы и перспективы / от вред.А.А.Гребеньков. Курск, 2014. С. 73. (Sinyaeva M.I., Skokova A.N. Stages of Crime Commission in Criminal Law and Criminal Law Science // Criminal Law in an Evolving Society: Problems and Prospects / Edited by A.A. Grebenkov. Kursk, 2014. P. 73.)
Майстренко Г.А. Стадии совершения преступления: научные концепции и правовое регулирование // Образование и право №10, 2020. –С. 299 (Maistrenko G.A. Stages of Crime Commission: Scientific Concepts and Legal Regulation // Education and Law, No. 10, 2020. – P. 299.)
Рустамбаев М.Х.Ўзбекистон Республикаси Жиноят кодексига шарҳлар. Умумий қисм / М.Рустамбаев –Тошкент: Yuridik adabiyotlar publish, 2021. – Б.228-229. (Rustambaev M.Kh. Commentary on the Criminal Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. General Part / M. Rustambaev – Tashkent: Yuridik adabiyotlar publish, 2021. – Pp. 22)
Salaev N.S., Niyozova S.S. Jinoyatlarni kvalifikatsiya qilish muammolari (Umumiy qism). Darslik . – T.: TDYuU nashriyoti, 2023. – B. 176. (Salaev N.S., Niyozova S.S. Problems of Crime Qualification (General Part). Textbook. – Tashkent: Tashkent State University of Law Publishing, 2023. – P. 176.)
Актуальные проблемы уголовного права. Часть Общая : учебник / под ред. Л. В. Иногамовой-Хегай. – 2-е изд., перераб. и доп. – Москва : Проспект, 2019. – С. 116. (Current Issues of Criminal Law. General Part: Textbook / Edited by L.V. Inogamova-Hegai. – 2nd ed., revised and supplemented. – Moscow: Prospekt, 2019. – P. 116.)
