HISTORY OF DEVELOPMENT AND THE NECESSITY INTRODUCING NORMS OF EXTREME NECESSITY INTO THE CRIMINAL CODE OF THE REPUBLIC OF UZBEKISTAN
Keywords:
extreme necessity, danger, harm, Islamic law, custom, exemption from responsibility, exemption from penaltyAbstract
This article analyzes the history of development in several stages of extreme necessity from ancient Roman law to its place in modern law as a circumstance excluding the criminality of an act. Studies have been carried out on the features of the development of norms on extreme necessity in the criminal law of the Republic of Uzbekistan during the period of Zoroastrianism, the period of Sharia with the advent of Islam, the period of Soviet power and the period of independence. Having studied the opinions of Ulpian, G. Grotsiy, X. Volf, S. Pufendorf, I.G. Gegel, Edward B. Arnolds, Kalman Gerocz and many other legal scholars, the theoretical conclusions set out in the article were made. The religious and secular rules of extreme necessity, which were formed and developed in a number of periods of history, were studied. The differences, shortcomings and achievements of the considered norms in the criminal codes of the Republic of Uzbekistan, adopted and in force over the past hundred years of history, are analyzed. Proposals and recommendations have been developed to improve the relevant norms of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan.
References
Edward B. Arnolds, Norman F. Garland, The Defense of Necessity in Criminal Law: The Right to Choose the Lesser Evil, J. Crim. L. & Criminology 289 (1974). Vol. 65, No.3., R.291.
Nikitenko M.G. Istoriko-pravovoy analiz razvitiya krayney neobxodimosti kak obstoyatelstva, isklyuchayuщego prestupnost deyaniya. Vestnik Xabarovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta ekonomiki i prava. 2021. № 1 (105) S. 84. (Nikitenko M.G. Historical and legal analysis of the development of extreme necessity as a circumstance precluding the criminality of an act. Bulletin of the Khabarovsk State University of Economics and Law. 2021. No. 1 (105) P. 84.)
Xvostov V.M. Istoriya rimskogo prava. - M., 1919. – S. 74-75. (Khvostov V.M. History of Roman law. - M., 1919. – P. 74-75.)
Pamyatniki rimskogo prava: zakonы XII tablits. Institutsii Gaya. Diggestы Yustiniana. M.: Zersalo, 1997. – S. 219-220. (Monuments of Roman law: laws of the XII tables. Guyanese Institutions. Digests of Justinian. M.: Zertsalo, 1997. – P. 219-220.)
Kálmán Gerőcz: Criminal Exigency. Budapest, Zemplén Nyomda, 1914. 73-74.
Ervin Belovics. Proportionality in extreme necessity. Iustum Aequum Salutare X. 2014. 2. R. 127.
Antonov V.F. Obstoyatelstva primeneniya instituta krayney neobxodimosti v deyatelnosti pravooxranitelnыx organov. Dissertatsiya ... kan. yur. nauk. – Moskva, 2000. – S. 16. (Antonov V.F. Circumstances of application of the institution of extreme necessity in the activities of law enforcement agencies. Dissertation ... can. legal Sciences. – Moscow, 2000. - P. 16.)
Of the Law of Nature and Nations: Eight Books, B. Kennett (trans.), …Fourth Edition. Done into English by Mr. [George] Carew, Buffalo, NY, Hein, 2005. Available at: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pufendorf-moral/
Viryasova N. V. Istoricheskiy aspekt krayney neobxodimosti // Nauchno-metodicheskiy elektronnыy jurnal «Konsept». – 2016. – T. 41. – S. 39–43. – URL: http://e-koncept.ru/2016/56915.htm. (Viryasova N.V. The historical aspect of extreme necessity // Scientific and methodological electronic journal "Concept". - 2016. - T. 41. - P. 39–43.) Available at: https://e-koncept.ru/2016/56915.htm.
The Cambridge Handbook of Human Dignity Interdisciplinary Perspectives. Cambridge University Press, 2014. pp. 215 - 221
Hegel: Base-line of Iurisphilosophy. Budapest, Akadémia Kiadó, 1983. 144-145.
Kant: Basics of Morals’ Metaphysics (Outlines of Iurisprudence). Budapest, Gondolat, 1991. 33–332.
The Zend Avesta: Part I The Vendidad. Translated by James Darmesteter. Oxford At the Clarendon press, 1880. P. 385.
Arabic translation available at: https://www.wordhippo.com/what-is/the/arabic-word-for-a4b7517fba785ebfef29a550c05717965e913b49.html
Аlau Adilbayev. V kakix sluchayax haram stanovitsa dozvolennim? (When does haram become permissible?) Available at: https://kazislam.kz/v-kakih-sluchayah-haram-stanovitsya-dozv/ [accessed 23.11.2021]
Z. Muqimov. O’zbekiston davalati va huquqi tarixi. Oliy o‘quv yurtlari talabalari uchun darslik. –T.: “Adolat”, 2003. – B. 100. (Z. Muqimov. History of the state and law of Uzbekistan. Textbook for university students. –T .: “Adolat”, 2003. - P. 100.)
Kamali, Mohammad Hashi. Crime and Punishment in Islamic Law: A Fresh Interpretation. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 2019. R. 236.
Muhammad bin Ali. Shariah Law and Hudud: Understanding Its Objectives and Spirit. Nanyang Technological university, Singapore. No. 204/2013 dated 1 November 2013. Available at: https://www.rsis.edu.sg/rsis-publication/rsis/2092-shariah-law-and-hudud-underst/#.YaJidFVBzDd
Medvedev A.A. Obstoyatelstva, isklyuchayuщiye ugolovnuyu otvetstvennost v islamskom ugolovnom prave. Voprosы rossiyskoy yustitsii. 2020. № 6. s. 438. (Medvedev A.A. Circumstances excluding criminal liability in Islamic criminal law. Issues of Russian justice. 2020. No. 6. p. 438.)
Baxronov X. Mustamlakachilikdan – mustaqillikkacha: O’zbekiston Respublikasi jinoyat-protsessual qonunchiligining rivojlanish tarixi. – T.: «Falsafa va huquq» nashriyoti, 2007. – B. 13-14. (Baxronov X. From colonialism to independence: the history of the development of criminal procedure legislation of the Republic of Uzbekistan. - T .: "Philosophy and Law" Publishing House, 2007. - P. 13-14.)
Mirenskiy B.A. Metodologicheskiye osnovы i metodы sovershenstvovaniya zakonodatelstva. Nukus: Karakalpakstan, 1990. – s. 23. (Mirensky B.A. Methodological bases and methods of improvement of the legislation. Nukus: Karakalpakstan, 1990. – p. 23.)
https://docs.cntd.ru/document/901757374
Ugolovniy kodeks Uzbekskoy SSR. – Tashkent: Yurid. Izd. NKYu UzSSR, 1926. (Criminal Code of the Uzbekistan SSR. – Tashkent: Jurid. Ed. NKJU of the Uzbek SSR, 1926.)
O’zbekiston SSRning Jinoyat kodeksi. (1971-yil 1 yanvargacha bo‘lgan O’zgarish va qo‘shimchalar bilan) – Toshkent: O’zbekiston, 1971. – B. 211. (Criminal Code of the Uzbekistan SSR. (As amended and supplemented before January 1, 1971) – Tashkent: Uzbekistan, 1971. – P. 211.)
