CLASSIFICATION OF CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN THE NORM MAKING PROCESS
Keywords:
Legislative acts, normative-legal act, norm-making, draft law, citizen participation, law-making, forms of citizen participationAbstract
The article classifies the main forms of citizen participation in the process of norm-making based on several criteria. In particular, according to the forms of participation; according to the subjects, the forms of citizen participation in the process of norm-making are discussed, divided into types. As a result of the discussion using the classification method, citizen participation in the process of norm-making manifests its various aspects. This is of great importance in developing the theoretical and legal foundations of the issue of involving citizens in the process of preparing and adopting draft normative legal acts.
References
Понкин И.В., Редкина А.И. Классификация как метод науchного исследования, в chастности в юридиchеской науке // Вестник Пермского университета. 2017. – №. 37. – C. 255. (Ponkin I.V., Redkina A.I. Classification as a method of scientific research, in particular in legal science // Bulletin of Perm University. 2017. - No. 37. - P. 255.)
Pearson K. The Grammar of Science. New York: Meridian Books, 1957. – P. 394.
Мейен С.В., Шрейдер Ю.А. Методологиchеские аспекты теории классификации // Вопросы философии. 1976. – №12. – С. 67 (Meyen S.V., Shreider Yu.A. Methodological aspects of classification theory // Questions of Philosophy. 1976. – No. 12. – P. 67)
Melody Y. Kiang. A comparative assessment of classification methods // Decision Support Systems. 2003. – №35. – P. 441
Багдасаров В.Ю. Основания классификации правотворchества // Журнал российского права. 2012. – №11. –С. 49 (Bagdasarov V.Yu. Grounds for classification of lawmaking // Journal of Russian Law. 2012. – No. 11. –P. 49)
Csaba Kiss. Legislative Decision-Making and Access Rights. 2008. – P. 12
Огнева. Е.А. Правовое регулирование правотворchеской инициативы граждан как гарантия реализации прав chеловека: зарубежные практики // Серия Философия. Социология. Право. 2013. – №16. – C. 190. (Ogneva. E.A. Legal regulation of citizens’ lawmaking initiative as a guarantee of human rights implementation: foreign practices // Series Philosophy. Sociology. Law. 2013. – No. 16. – P. 190.)
Dominik Steiger. A constitutional theory of imperative participation: delegated rulemaking, citizens’ participation and the separation of powers doctrine // Albany Law Review. 2016. – №79/1. – P. 63.
Marina Pietrangelo. Legislative drafting and online consultation: a contribute to lawmaking for better regulation?. Working Paper Series. 2019. – №53. – P. 10.
Code of good practice for civil participation in the decision-making process. Conference materials of International Non-Governmental Organisations (INGOs) of the Council of Europe. 2019. – P. 12.
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi qonun hujjatlari to‘plami, 2015 y., 51-son, 637-modda; Qonunchilik ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 28.07.2021 y., 10/21/3313/0724-son (Collection of Legislative Acts of the Republic of Uzbekistan, 2015, No. 51, Article 637; National Database of Legislative Information, 28.07.2021, No. 10/21/3313/0724)
Sodikov A. Some problems of norm-making process in support with information // Yuridik fanlar axborotnomasi. 2020. – №3-son. – B. 5. (Newsletter of Legal Sciences. 2020. – Issue №3. – P. 5.)
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining “Davlat organlari va tashkilotlarining faoliyati ochiqligini ta’minlash, shuningdek, jamoatchilik nazoratini samarali amalga oshirishga doir qo‘shimcha chora-tadbirlar to‘g‘risida”gi Farmoni // Qonunchilik ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 17.06.2021 y., 06/21/6247/0563-son, 09.04.2022 y., 06/22/101/0288-son, 15.06.2022 y., 06/22/154/0524-son (13. Decree of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On additional measures to ensure the openness of the activities of state bodies and organizations, as well as the effective implementation of public control” // National database of legislative information, 17.06.2021, No. 06/21/6247/0563, 09.04.2022, No. 06/22/101/0288, 15.06.2022, No. 06/22/154/0524)
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining “Norma ijodkorligi faoliyatini takomillashtirish konsepsiyasini tasdiqlash to‘g‘risida”gi Farmoni // Qonun hujjatlari ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 08.08.2018 y., 06/18/5505/1639-son; 09.11.2019 y., 06/19/5870/4010-son; Qonunchilik ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 30.04.2021 y., 06/21/6218/0398-son (Decree of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On approval of the Concept of improving the activity of normative acts” // National database of legislative documents, 08.08.2018, No. 06/18/5505/1639; 09.11.2019, No. 06/19/5870/4010; National database of legislative documents, 30.04.2021, No. 06/21/6218/0398)
Афиногенов Д.В. Законодателная инициатива граждан и их объединений в Российской Федерации // URL: http://www.civisbook.ru (Afinogenov D.V. Legislative initiative of citizens and their associations in the Russian Federation // URL: http://www.civisbook.ru)
Об общественном договоре. Трактаты / Пер. с фр. — М.: «КАНОН-пресс», «Куchково поле», 1998. — С. 56 (On the Social Contract. Treatises / Translated from French. — M.: "CANON-press", "Kuchkovo Pole", 1998. — P. 56)
O‘zbekiston Respublikasining “Normativ-huquqiy hujjatlar to‘g‘risida”gi Qonuni // Qonunchilik ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 20.04.2021 y., 03/21/682/0354-son; Qonunchilik ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 03.03.2022 y., 03/22/756/0180-son. (Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan "On Regulatory and Legal Acts" // National Database of Legislative Information, 04/20/2021, No. 03/21/682/0354; National Database of Legislative Information, 03/03/2022, No. 03/22/756/0180.)
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Fuqarolik kodeksiga sharh. 1-jild (birinchi qism) Adliya vazirligi. – T.: «Vektor-Press», 2010.– 816 b.–(Professional (malakali) sharhlar). (Commentary on the Civil Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. Volume 1 (part one) Ministry of Justice. – T.: “Vector-Press”, 2010.– 816 p.– (Professional (qualified) comments))
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Fuqarolik kodeksiga sharh. 1-jild (birinchi qism) Adliya vazirligi. – T.: «Vektor-Press», 2010.– 816 b.–(Professional (malakali) sharhlar). (Commentary on the Civil Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. Volume 1 (part one) Ministry of Justice. – T.: “Vector-Press”, 2010.– 816 p.– (Professional (qualified) comments))
Акилов А. Значение сравнителного законоведения на современном этапе развития страны // Qонунchилик муаммолари ахборотномаси. 2021. – №1. – Б. 49. (21. Akilov A. The Importance of Comparative Law at the Current Stage of the Country’s Development // Newsletter of legislative problems. 2021. – #1. - B. 49.)
O‘zbekiston Respublikasining “Qonun loyihalarining umumxalq muhokamasi to‘g‘risida”gi Qonuni // O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Oliy Majlisining Axborotnomasi, 2001 y., 1-2-son, 14-modda; O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Qonun hujjatlari to‘plami, 2004 y., 51-son, 514-modda; Qonun hujjatlari ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 05.09.2019 y., 03/19/563/3685-son; Qonunchilik ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 21.04.2021 y., 03/21/683/0375-son (Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan "On Public Discussion of Draft Laws" // Bulletin of the Oliy Majlis of the Republic of Uzbekistan, 2001, No. 1-2, Article 14; Collection of Legislation of the Republic of Uzbekistan, 2004, No. 51, Article 514; National Database of Legislative Documents, 05.09.2019, No. 03/19/563/3685; National Database of Legislative Data, 21.04.2021, No. 03/21/683/0375)
European Commission. Better regulation guidelines – Stakeholder consultations. available at https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/better-regulation-guidelines-stakeholderconsultation.pdf
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining “Fuqarolarning huquq va erkinliklarini ta’minlash hamda huquqiy xizmat ko‘rsatishda adliya organlari va muassasalari faoliyati samaradorligini yanada oshirish chora-tadbirlari to‘g‘risida”gi Farmoni // Qonunchilik ma’lumotlari milliy bazasi, 18.03.2022 y., 06/22/89/0227-son (Decree of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On measures to further increase the efficiency of the activities of justice bodies and institutions in ensuring the rights and freedoms of citizens and providing legal services” // National Database of Legislative Information, 18.03.2022, No. 06/22/89/0227)
Piotr Mikuli, Grzegorz Kuca. The Public Hearing and Law-Making Procedures. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10991-016-9177. Published online: 27 February 2016
Tanja Aitamurto. Collective Intelligence in Law Reforms: When the Logic of the Crowds and the Logic of Policymaking Collide. https://www.researchgate.net/
Tulyakov E. Jamoatchilik nazoratida jarayon emas, natija muhim. https://strategy.uz/index.php?news=799 (Tulyakov E. In public control, the result is important, not the process. https://strategy.uz/index.php?news=799)
Гонchаров В.В. — Сущност и значение категории «общественный контрол власти» // Политика и Общество. – 2018. – № 10. – С. 9 (Goncharov V.V. - The essence and meaning of the category "public control of power" // Politics and Society. - 2018. - No. 10. - P. 9)
