LEGAL-COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF FAMILY (DOMESTIC) VIOLENCE AND INSULT
Keywords:
family (domestic) violence, insult, emotional abuse, administrative offenseAbstract
This article addresses the challenges in properly qualifying offenses related to family (domestic) violence and insults due to the similarities between Part 1 of Article 592 and Article 41 of the Code of Administrative Liability of the Republic of Uzbekistan. The research reveals a prevalent issue where inquiry authorities often misqualify acts of insult that occur between partners as instances of family (domestic) violence. An analysis of 150 court decisions indicates that in 120 cases, the courts found that the inquiry bodies misqualified the actions. This misqualification primarily stems from an inadequate comprehension of the object, objective aspect, and subjective aspects of family (domestic) violence. The article distinguishes between the characteristics of family (domestic) violence and insult, examining the criteria for these offenses to provide a clearer framework for their qualification. Additionally, it reviews relevant scholarly perspectives on the subject and supports the authors’ arguments with a rationale aimed at improving legal classifications and outcomes in such cases.
References
Salamova S. Ya. Domestic violence in modern Russia: general characteristics // Lex Russica. 2018. No.9 (142). pp. 129-138.
Batyukova V. E. Some criminal law and criminological aspects of domestic violence // Law and Management scientific and legal journal. 2024. No.3. p.159.
Ganley A. L. Understanding domestic violence //Improving the health care response to domestic violence: A resource manual for health care providers. – 1995. – P. 20
Trevillion K., Oram S., Howard L. M. Domestic violence and mental health //Domestic Violence and Mental Health. – 2013. – С. 18.
Astbury J. et al. The impact of domestic violence on individuals //Medical Journal of Australia. – 2000. – Т. 173. – №. 8. – С. 427-432.
Рустамбаев М.Х. Курс уголовного права Республики Узбекистан. Особенная часть. Том 3. Преступления против личности, мира и безопасности. Учебник для ВУЗов. 2- издание, дополненное и переработанное– Т.: Военно-технический институт Национальной гвардии Республики Узбекистан, 2018. – с. 267-268 (Rustambaev M.Kh. Criminal Law Course of the Republic of Uzbekistan. Special Part. Volume 3. Crimes against the Person, Peace and Security. Textbook for Universities. 2nd Edition, Supplemented and Revised – T.: Military-Technical Institute of the National Guard of the Republic of Uzbekistan, 2018. – pp. 267-268)
Уголовное право. Особенная часть: Учебник. Издание второе исправленное и дополненное / Под ред. доктора юридических на-ук, профессора Л.В. Иногамовой-Хегай, доктора юридических на-ук, профессора А.И. Рарога, доктора юридических наук, профессора А.И. Чучаева. — М.: Юридическая фирма «КОНТРАКТ»: ИНФРА-М, 2008. — 106 с. (Criminal Law. Special Part: Textbook. Second Edition, Revised and Supplemented / Ed. by Doctor of Law, Professor L.V. Inogamova-Khegay, Doctor of Law, Professor A.I. Rarog, Doctor of Law, Professor A.I. Chuchaev. — M.: Law Firm "CONTRACT": INFRA-M, 2008. — 106 p.)
Сидорова И. В. Оскорбление как разновидность психического насилия //Психопедагогика в правоохранительных органах. – 2017. – №. 1 (68). – С. 28-32. (Sidorova I.V. Insult as a Type of Mental Violence // Psychopedagogy in Law Enforcement Agencies. – 2017. – No. 1 (68). – P. 28-32)
Иванин Александр Александрович Особенности состава оскорбления личности как административного правонарушения // Вестник БГУ. 2019. №4 (42). (Ivanin Alexander Alexandrovich Features of the composition of an insult to a person as an administrative offense // Bulletin of BSU. 2019. No. 4 (42).) URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/osobennosti-sostava-oskorblenija-lichnosti-kak-administrativnogo-pravonarushenija (дата обращения: 09.08.2024).
Омельченко С. С. Объективные признаки состава оскорбления // Актуальные проблемы российского права. 2008. №3. (Omelchenko S. S. Objective features of the composition of an insult // Actual problems of Russian law. 2008. No. 3.) URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/obektivnye-priznaki-sostava-oskorblenija (дата обращения: 09.08.2024).
Культикова В. В., Жарич В. Т., Бочков П. В. Актуальные вопросы толкования оскорбления как административного правонарушения //Право в современном мире: достижение метабезопасности как атрибута. – 2020. – С. 84. (Kul'tikova V. V., Zharich V. T., Bochkov P. V. Actual issues of interpretation of insult as an administrative offense // Law in the modern world: achieving metasecurity as an attribute. - 2020. - P. 84)
Ищенко Д. П., Басов А. В., Ищенко Г. К. Правова ОЦЕНКА ОСКОРБЛЕНИЯ, КАК АДМИНИСТРАТИВНОГО ПРАВОНАРУШЕНИЯ И УГОЛОВНО НАКАЗУЕМОГО ДЕЯНИЯ // Ученые записки Крымского федерального университета имени В. И. Вернадского. Юридические науки. 2021. №2. – С. 285. (Ishchenko D. P., Basov A. V., Ishchenko G. K. Pravova ASSESSMENT OF INSULT AS AN ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES AND A CRIMINAL PUNISHABLE ACT // Scientific notes of the Crimean Federal University named after V. I. Vernadsky. Legal sciences. 2021. No. 2. - P. 285) URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/pravovaja-otsenka-oskorblenija-kak-administrativnogo-pravonarushenija-i-ugolovno-nakazuemogo-dejanija (дата обращения: 11.08.2024).
Burke A. S. Domestic violence as a crime of pattern and intent: An alternative reconceptualization //Geo. Wash. L. Rev. – 2006. – Т. 75. – С. 552.
Dutton D. G. The domestic assault of women: Psychological and criminal justice perspectives. – UBC press, 1995. – P.8.
