ON THE ERRONEOUS INTERPRETATION OF THE ORIGIN AND TIME OF THE APPEARANCE OF THE CATACOMB TYPE OF BURIAL IN THE BRONZE AGE IN CENTRAL ASIA
Keywords:
Zamanbaba, Sapalli culture, V.A. Gorodtsov, dissertation of Yu.G. Kutimov, Dulana Bulak, Taipan, Ertash Dulana, Kavardan, Migration, Sarmatians, Prokhorovka culture, Tillatepa, Early Tulkhar, Kaunchi cultureAbstract
This article examines the origin of ancient catacomb-type graves, about its erroneous use at one time in relation to the graves of the Zamanbaba culture based on the historiography of Soviet archeology. At one time, V.A. Gorodtsov also mistakenly called the undercut graves catacomb, as evidenced by his graphic drawings. Our further studies of real catacomb graves on the territory of the Akhangaron Valley showed what a catacomb-type grave is, its internal structure and the time of its appearance in Central Asia. Unfortunately, Russian colleagues-archaeologists, without delving into the internal structure of catacomb-type graves, repeat the terminological errors of Soviet historiography, as evidenced by the candidate dissertation of Yu.G. Kutimova “The origin and ways of spreading the catacomb burial rite in Central Asia (based on the materials of the burial grounds of the Bronze Age) to which the authors' self-critical approach to determining the time of the appearance of the catacomb device of graves is devoted, also criticizes Russian colleagues in the interpretation and interpretation of archaeological sources of Central Asia in the Soviet conservatism historiography.
References
Гулямов, Я.Г. Археологические работы к западу от Бухарского оазиса. «Труды института истории и археологии АН Уз ССР», вып. VIII, Ташкент, 1956; Массон В.М. Изучение энеолита и бронзового века Средней Азии. СА, 1957, №4, с.48-49; Латынин Б.А. О южных границах ойкумены степных культур эпохи бронзы. СА, 1958,№3, с.49-53; Кузьмина Е.Е. Могильник Заманбаба. СЭ, 1958,№3; Аскаров А. Культура Заманбаба в низовьях Зарафшана. «ОНУ», 1962, №11,с.59-65. (Archaeological work west of the Bukhara oasis. "Proceedings of the Institute of History and Archeology of the Academy of Sciences of the Uzbek SSR", vol. VIII, Tashkent, 1956; Masson V.M. Study of the Eneolithic and Bronze Age of Central Asia. CA, 1957, No. 4, pp. 48-49; Latynin B.A. About the southern borders of the ecumene of steppe cultures of the Bronze Age. CA, 1958, No. 3, pp. 49-53; Kuzmina E.E. Burial ground of Zamanbaba. SE, 1958, No. 3; Askarov A. Culture of Zamanbaba in the lower reaches of Zarafshan. "ONU", 1962, No. 11, pp. 59-65.)
Кутимов Ю.Г. Происхождение и пути распространения катакомбного обряда погребений в Средней Азии (по материалам могильников бронзового века). Кандидатская диссертация. Санкт-Петербург-2009 ( Kutimov Yu.G. The origin and ways of spreading the catacomb burial rite in Central Asia (based on materials from the burial grounds of the Bronze Age). PhD thesis. St. Petersburg-2009).
Аскаров А. Сапаллитепа. Ташкент-1973, стр.42, Сводная таблица; Его же. Древнеземледельческая культура эпохи бронзы юга Узбекистана. Ташкент-1977, стр.38-46. Табл.№№I-XIV.
Аскаров А, Инамов О, Исабеков Б. Комплекс погребальных памятников «Дулана Булок» в верховьях реки Ахангарана и его изучение (Askarov A, Inamov O, Isabekov B. Complex of burial monuments "Dulana Bulok" in the upper reaches of the Akhangaran river and its study)
Исабеков Б.И. Қовунчи маданияти этник гурухлари Чотқол ва Қурама тоғ чўққиларида (Isabekov B.I. The ethnic groups of the Kaunchi culture are in the Chatkal and Qurama mountain peaks.)
Монгайт А.Л. «Археология в СССР».Москва-1955, с.125, таблица катакомбные погребения (Mongayt A.L. "Archeology in the USSR". Moscow-1955, p. 125, table catacomb burials).
Аскаров А. и др. Первобытная культура в Низовьях Зарафшана. Ташкент-1966, стр.128-129; Его же. Сапаллитепа. Ташкент-2973, стр.42, Сводная таблица; Его же. Древнеземледельческая культура эпохи бронзы юга Узбекистана. Ташкент-1977, стр.38-46. Табл.№№I-XIV (Askarov A. et al. Primitive culture in the lower reaches of Zarafshan. Tashkent-1966, pp. 128-129; Its the same. Sapallitepa. Tashkent-2973, p. 42, Summary table; Its the same. Ancient agricultural culture of the Bronze Age in the south of Uzbekistan. Tashkent-1977, pp. 38-46. Table No. I-XIV.)
Sarianidi V.I. Baktrisches Gold. Aus den Ausgrabungren der Nekropole yonTilja-Tepe in nordafghanistan. Aurora-Kunstverlag. Leningrad-1985 (8. Sarianidi V.I. Bactrian gold. From the excavations of the necropolis of Tilja-Tepe in northern Afghanistan. Aurora Art Publishing. Leningrad-1985).
Аскаров А. Арийская проблема: новые подходы и взгляды. «История Узбекистана в археологических и письменных источниках».Ташкент-2005, стр.89 (Askarov A. Aryan problem: new approaches and views. "History of Uzbekistan in archaeological and written sources". Tashkent-2005, p. 89).
Аскаров А. История происхождения узбекского народа.Ташкент, Изд. «Узбекистан» 2018, с. 306-336 (Askarov A. History of the origin of the Uzbek people. Tashkent, Ed. "Uzbekistan" 2018, p. 306-336)
